Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pridwin Hotel |
8.7 / 10 (70 Reviews) |
From 334$ | |
| Sunset Beach |
8.2 / 10 (8 Reviews) |
From 596$ | |
| Montauk Manor |
9.0 / 10 (1263 Reviews) |
From 157$ | |
| Saybrook Point Resort & Marina |
9.3 / 10 (300 Reviews) |
From 294$ | |
| Hotel Marcel New Haven, Tapestry Collection By Hilton |
9.0 / 10 (542 Reviews) |
From 409$ |
Top luxury hotels in Shelter Island
View all photos
The Pridwin Hotel
From 334$
View all photos
Sunset Beach
From 596$
View all photos
Montauk Manor
From 157$
Spa luxury hotels in Shelter Island
View all photos
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
From 294$
View all photos
Hotel Marcel New Haven, Tapestry Collection By Hilton
From 409$
Hotels in Shelter Island
| Best reviews Hotel ❤️ | The Pridwin Hotel |
| Top Service Hotel 🛁 | Sunset Beach |
| Best Price Hotel 🤑 | Montauk Manor |
View all photos
Circle Hotel Fairfield
From 174$
View all photos
The Shoals Suites & Slips
From 199$
View all photos
Quality Suites Stratford
From 90$
View all photos
Hyatt Regency Long Island
From 109$
View all photos
Sleep Inn & Suites Niantic North
From 140$
View all photos
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg
From 410$
View all photos
Grand Lake Hotel
From 95$
View all photos
The Hotel Maria
From 462$
View all photos
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
From 710$
View all photos
Hotel Hi-Ho - Contactless Check-In
From 102$