Top Luxury Hotels

Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island

We've selected 15 of the Best Luxury hotels in Shelter Island for your 2026 vacation!

Select dates
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

Top luxury hotels in Shelter Island

View all photos

8.5
Very good
59 Reviews

From

334$/night

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road
Check Availability

View all photos

8.2
Very good
8 Reviews

From

596$/night

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road
Check Availability

View all photos

9
Excellent
1217 Reviews

From

157$/night

Montauk Manor

236 Edgemere Street
Check Availability

Spa luxury hotels in Shelter Island

View all photos

9.2
Excellent
266 Reviews

From

294$/night

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

Two Bridge Street
Check Availability

View all photos

8.8
Excellent
553 Reviews

From

179$/night

Hotel Marcel New Haven, Tapestry Collection By Hilton

500 Sargent Drive
Check Availability

View all photos

8.2
Very good
572 Reviews

From

174$/night

Circle Hotel Fairfield

417 Post Road
Check Availability

View all photos

9.6
Excellent
37 Reviews

From

199$/night

The Shoals Suites & Slips

61600 Main Road
Check Availability

View all photos

7.5
Very good
558 Reviews

From

90$/night

Quality Suites Stratford

1500 South Avenue
Check Availability

View all photos

7.6
Very good
445 Reviews

From

109$/night

Hyatt Regency Long Island

1717 Motor Parkway
Check Availability

View all photos

7.8
Very good
311 Reviews

From

140$/night

Sleep Inn & Suites Niantic North

5 King Arthur
Check Availability

View all photos

9.1
Excellent
136 Reviews

From

163$/night

Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

1830 West Main St (Rt 25)
Check Availability

View all photos

7.2
Good
231 Reviews

From

69$/night

Grand Lake Hotel

1667 Exeter Road
Check Availability

View all photos

9.4
Excellent
87 Reviews

From

207$/night

The Hotel Maria

132 Atlantic Avenue
Check Availability

View all photos

9.6
Excellent
117 Reviews

From

251$/night

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

1400 Silvermere Road
Check Availability

View all photos

7.2
Good
443 Reviews

From

102$/night

Hotel Hi-Ho - Contactless Check-In

4180 Black Rock Turnpike
Check Availability

Location

Shelter Island, New York State, United States, 11964

Contact Us

YOUR DETAILS
SUBJECT
MESSAGE